I ended up getting a magnificent Turtle Brownie and a hot chocolate with loads of delicious whipped cream and drizzled chocolate syrup. It was divine! As I perused the build-your-own-sandwich menu, I decided I had to order a sandwich. You pick your own bread, then meat, then cheese, then condiments. I selected London broil with cheddar on ciabatta with lettuce, lettuce tomato, cucumber avocado and peppered mayonnaise. It was fantastic.
I chatted with the owner, Allison, for a few minutes. I loved that she carries a few items for sale in her store - popcorn, sauces and other items and almost all of those items are made locally by small businesses in Northwest Indiana.
The fresh baked goods looked wonderful. Call about ordering a homemade pie or other goodies.
Pie Eyed is in an old brick building on a corner on the historic main street. The windows in front are done in vintage-style lettering and it has such a nostalgic view. That's what totally drew me in.
I can't wait to stop by again and try something new!
1600 119th Street